Democratic candidate Zohran Mamdani is poised to become New York City's first Muslim and South Asian mayor, a groundbreaking achievement that could energize and galvanize these communities, as noted by voters and experts in a recent interview with ABC News. Asif Mahmood, a prominent Democratic bundler who has previously supported Hillary Clinton and Kamala Harris, as well as run for Congress himself, expressed that this victory will significantly impact South Indians, Muslims, and immigrants like himself, instilling a sense of belonging in America.
Historically, South Asian and Arab Muslims in the United States, especially those who immigrated post-1965, have often been disengaged from the political process. According to reports by ABC News, Asian-Americans generally have been underrepresented in polling and political research, even during recent election cycles. However, Mamdani's rise to national prominence could shift this narrative, as his campaign has witnessed a remarkable mobilization of these communities. Data from research firm L2 indicates that South Asian voter turnout in the 2025 NYC primary election surged by approximately 40% compared to the 2021 primary.
Mahmood highlighted the growing interest among South Asians and Muslims in New York politics, although he expressed concerns about the sustainability of this engagement. He remains skeptical about whether this newfound political energy will extend to future candidates. The focus on identity throughout this election has been particularly pronounced, with Mamdani's campaign embracing it while facing criticism from his opponents.
Born in Uganda and of Indian descent, Mamdani has lived in the United States since the age of seven, becoming a naturalized citizen in 2018. Dora Pekec, a spokesperson for Mamdani, remarked that this campaign has sparked a powerful awakening within New York's South Asian and Muslim communities, offering them visibility, pride, and a sense of political belonging that has long been denied.
Vishvajit Singh, a storyteller and artist residing in NYC, echoed this sentiment, stating that the excitement to vote extends beyond just the South Asian community. He noted that both supporters and critics of Mamdani’s candidacy could benefit from his rise, potentially opening pathways for South Asians, or 'desis', in U.S. governance. Singh emphasized that Mamdani's success could inspire children from diverse backgrounds, including those of Hispanic descent, to aspire to significant government roles.
Raza Ahmad Rumi, a policy analyst and lecturer at the City University of New York, remarked on how Mamdani’s ascent signifies a generational shift in New York politics. His charisma and ability to connect with a broad audience, including support from white and Jewish youth, demonstrate that his appeal transcends mere identity politics.
The impact of Mamdani's candidacy stretches beyond New York, resonating with community members across the nation and even internationally. Mahmood, based in California, noted that virtually every South Asian he knows is aware of the significance of this race. Dr. Naomi Green, assistant-secretary general for the Muslims Council of Britain, highlighted that Mamdani's widespread support indicates a collective preference for justice and inclusion over prejudice.
The election of NYC's first Muslim mayor is a notable milestone, especially in a city that has grappled with Islamophobia following the tragic events of 9/11. Mamdani's campaign has aimed to address this issue head-on, accusing his opponent, former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, of employing Islamophobic rhetoric. Cuomo has countered these claims, arguing that Mamdani is being divisive and misrepresenting his statements.
However, the election landscape is not without its challenges. In October, Cuomo launched a coalition called South Asians for Cuomo, which attracted some support away from Mamdani. The Indian community, in particular, has shown divisions, with critics questioning Mamdani's economic policies and even labeling him as anti-Hindu due to his past comments about Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The Mamdani campaign has not yet issued a formal response to these allegations.
Fahad Solaiman, a member of the Jackson Heights Bangladeshi Business Development Association, expressed skepticism regarding the feasibility of Mamdani's promises, labeling them as unrealistic. He emphasized that while there are many South Asian Americans in public office, the focus should be on the substance of the promises made, rather than merely the identity of those in power.
Mamdani has also faced backlash from certain members of the Jewish community, with over 1,000 rabbis nationwide signing a letter condemning his rhetoric concerning Israel. His candidacy emerges at a time when there is a noted decline in Democratic support among Indian-Americans. The Carnegie Endowment for International Peace has reported a decrease in Indian-Americans voting for Democratic candidates in 2024 compared to 2020, despite the presence of former Vice President Kamala Harris on the ticket.
Additionally, a recent Pew Research Center report indicated a decline in Muslim support for Democrats, with 42% of Muslims identifying with or leaning towards the Republican Party in 2024, a significant increase from just 13% in 2017. Mahmood stressed that while Mamdani's identity is a facet of his candidacy, it does not define it. He articulated that Mamdani is a capable mayor who happens to be Muslim and South Asian, emphasizing the importance of his qualifications over his identity.
