On Friday, Nintendo (NTDOF) stock experienced a decline as the video game giant grapples with a distinct challenge surrounding the Switch 2. Although the console achieved remarkable success by selling 3.5 million units within just four days, third-party developers are reporting disappointing sales figures that fall short of their expectations.
One notable developer indicated that sales for its games on the Switch 2 were “below our lowest estimates.” This situation highlights a concerning trend: a staggering 81% of physical game sales for the Switch 2 are dominated by first-party titles, such as Nintendo's flagship Mario Kart World and enhanced versions of previous Switch games. This over-reliance on first-party games poses a significant risk for Nintendo's future as it may deter third-party developers from supporting the platform.
If third-party developers choose to withdraw their support due to poor sales, it could severely limit the variety of games available on the Switch 2, ultimately reducing its appeal to a broader audience of gamers.
Several critical issues contribute to the lackluster performance of third-party games on the Switch 2. One primary concern is the use of Game Key Cards. These unique cartridges, which do not contain the actual game, allow users to download the title from Nintendo's online store. While this method helps third-party developers save on cartridge costs, it fails to satisfy both physical collectors and digital players. Collectors prefer having the game physically on the cartridge, while digital users dislike the inconvenience of switching cartridges frequently.
A glaring example of this issue is the performance of CD Projekt’s Cyberpunk 2077, which stands as the best-selling third-party title on the Switch 2. Unlike other third-party games, it comes with the full game on the cartridge, showcasing the potential success of traditional physical releases.
Another significant factor impacting third-party sales on the Switch 2 is the age of many available games. Numerous titles have been available on other consoles and PC for years before their arrival on the Switch 2. Compounding this issue, developers often charge inflated prices for these older games, despite them being discounted on competing platforms. For instance, Yakuza 0 is currently priced at $50 on the Switch 2 while it is available for as low as $20 on Steam, and discounts have even seen it dip to $5.
This pricing strategy has led to frustration among gamers, as developers like Sega (SGAMY) request more than double the typical price for a decade-old game, all while offering a Game Key Card as the physical release, which further diminishes its appeal to collectors.
As of Friday morning, NTDOF stock was down 3.65%, although it remains up 50.73% year-to-date and has increased by 72.21% over the past 12 months. Addressing the issues faced by third-party game developers is crucial for Nintendo, as failure to do so may hinder or even reverse its recent stock growth.
When analyzing Nintendo's stock, Wall Street has issued a consensus rating of Moderate Buy. This rating is based on eight Buy ratings, two Hold ratings, and a single Sell rating recorded over the past three months. The average price target for NTDOF stock stands at $92.26, indicating a potential upside of 5.11% for investors.
For those seeking more information on NTDOF stock and analyst ratings, or looking for a suitable trading platform, consider exploring TipRanks' resources for guidance on smart investment decisions.
