As we dive into Week 9 of the fantasy football season, we present you with Quick Grades, your essential guide for making informed start/sit decisions. This analysis combines consensus rankings and projections, alongside matchup insights from The Primer, to deliver comprehensive letter grades for every fantasy-relevant player. Each grade serves as your default stance, while the accompanying notes provide context to help you navigate your weekly lineup with clarity. Remember, an 'A' signifies a player you can start with confidence, a 'C' indicates a matchup-dependent decision, and an 'F' suggests a player to bench. Scroll down for position-specific grades and key notes that explain the reasoning behind each assessment.
To facilitate quick scanning, we present the overall Week 9 rankings at the forefront. Below, you'll find detailed breakdowns for each position—Quarterback (QB), Running Back (RB), Wide Receiver (WR), Tight End (TE), Defense/Special Teams (DST), and Kicker (K)—complete with letter grades and concise notes. Utilize these rankings for a holistic view, then delve into specific position sections for the rationale behind each grade.
Caleb Williams (QB) has struggled recently, finishing as the QB20 or lower in three of his last four games. Despite ranking QB14 in fantasy points per game, his performance has been lackluster, with no game exceeding 25 rushing yards. He ranks poorly in accuracy metrics, making him a risky start against a Bengals defense that has allowed significant passing production. Grade: C.
Joe Flacco (QB) is dealing with a shoulder injury but is expected to play. His performance has been solid in two of his three starts, ranking high in passing yards per game. Facing a Bears defense that has struggled against the pass, Flacco is a viable QB1 option this week. Grade: B.
Bo Nix (QB) is showing flashes but remains inconsistent, ranking 32nd in yards per attempt among qualifying passers. With a tough matchup against a Houston defense that has excelled in limiting passing yards, it’s best to avoid starting Nix unless absolutely necessary. Grade: D.
C.J. Stroud (QB) has had some promising outings but still ranks as a QB2 in fantasy points per game. With a challenging matchup against a strong Denver pass defense, Stroud’s fantasy potential appears limited this week. Grade: C.
Jaxson Dart (QB) has been impressive, ranking as the QB6 in fantasy points since Week 4. Despite a slight dip in rushing production, he faces a 49ers defense that has struggled lately, making him a strong start this week. Grade: B.
Wan'Dale Robinson (WR) has shown solid production, with a 22.9% target share and a favorable matchup against the 49ers. Given the secondary's struggles, Robinson is poised for a productive game. Grade: B.
Jauan Jennings (WR) has emerged as a key target in the 49ers' offense, showing strong usage metrics. Facing a porous secondary, he is a reliable flex option this week. Grade: B.
Alec Pierce (WR) has excelled as a deep threat, making him a strong flex play against a Steelers defense vulnerable to downfield targets. His ability to exploit coverage weaknesses bodes well for his fantasy outlook. Grade: B.
Josh Downs (WR) has consistent production and faces a favorable matchup against a Steelers secondary that has struggled against slot receivers. He is a solid flex start this week. Grade: B.
Ladd McConkey (WR) has been on fire since Week 5, ranking high in fantasy points. Despite potential coverage challenges, he should still be in line for significant targets. Grade: B.
TreVeyon Henderson (RB) is a risky play, having shown limited production despite last week's decent numbers. With a tough matchup against Atlanta’s defense, it’s prudent to approach him with caution. Grade: C.
Ashton Jeanty (RB) has been a solid performer, ranking RB17 in fantasy points. However, he faces a challenging matchup, making him a volume-dependent play this week. Grade: C.
Travis Etienne Jr. (RB) is a volume play this week, but the Raiders' defense poses a significant challenge. His potential for a touchdown makes him start-worthy, albeit with caution. Grade: C.
Kareem Hunt (RB) steps into a leading role and could have a strong fantasy day based on volume and opportunities near the goal line. He is a viable flex option. Grade: B.
Kenneth Walker III (RB) has struggled lately but has the potential to break a long run against a favorable Washington defense. He remains a risky yet intriguing start. Grade: C.
T.J. Hockenson (TE) has underperformed this season but faces a defense that has allowed considerable yardage to tight ends. He could flirt with TE1 numbers if he finds the end zone. Grade: C.
Cole Kmet (TE) returns from injury and could see significant targets. Depending on his workload, he may be a deep streaming option this week. Grade: C.
Theo Johnson (TE) has been solid but faces a tough matchup against a stout San Francisco defense. He is best left on the bench this week. Grade: D.
Oronde Gadsden II (TE) has been productive and could continue to thrive despite a challenging matchup. Keep expectations reasonable but consider him a viable TE option. Grade: C.
With this comprehensive guide to Week 9 Fantasy Football Start/Sit Grades, you are equipped to make informed decisions for your lineup. For a more personalized experience, consider syncing your team for a tailored My Primer analysis. Let’s tackle this week’s matchups with confidence!