This summer has proven to be a record-breaking transfer window in the Premier League, with a staggering 155 players acquired for a combined total of £3.11 billion ($4.2 billion). This amount is enough to cover half the annual gross domestic product of the Isle of Man. Among these signings, some players are poised to become game-changing additions for their clubs, while others may struggle and find themselves on loan to lower-tier teams like Charlton Athletic. In an effort to evaluate these transfers, we at The Athletic have ranked them from worst to best based on various criteria.
It’s important to note that this list is not solely based on player ability. Factors such as cost-effectiveness, the significance of the player to their new team, and whether they address critical positional needs have also been taken into account. We have focused exclusively on senior, first-team players, leaving out those who have moved directly to under-21 teams or have been immediately loaned out.
As we dive into the list, please feel free to share your thoughts and reactions in the comments below. Let's see who made the top and who fell short!
Transfer Fee: Nominal
Contract Length: One Year
After making just one appearance in four years at Chelsea, Bettinelli will be fortunate to see the pitch at City, where he faces stiff competition from several goalkeepers.
Transfer Fee: Loan
Contract Length: One Year
Guiu's stint at Sunderland was short-lived, with three appearances and one goal before being recalled to Chelsea.
Transfer Fee: £20 million (with add-ons)
Contract Length: Five Years
Broja's track record raises concerns as he scored only three goals in 58 appearances across three seasons, making him a risky signing for Burnley.
Transfer Fee: Nominal
Contract Length: Two Years
The 30-year-old goalkeeper has been a backup option at Wolves and is expected to fill a similar role at Everton.
Transfer Fee: £12.9 million
Contract Length: Five Years
This young winger has potential but comes with a question mark after limited contributions in Serie A.
Transfer Fee: Free
Contract Length: One Year
Woodman transitions from a starting role in the Championship to a backup position at Liverpool, helping with the homegrown quota.
Transfer Fee: Free
Contract Length: One Year
Gunn joins Forest as a non-playing third-choice goalkeeper, adding depth to the squad.
Transfer Fee: £4.3 million
Contract Length: Four Years
Weiss, a young goalkeeper, offers a developing option for Burnley after a solid season in the German second division.
Transfer Fee: £5.2 million
Contract Length: Four Years
At 6ft 3in, Bornauw adds height to Leeds' defense but has yet to see significant playing time in the Premier League.
Transfer Fee: Loan
Contract Length: One Year
Sancho's loan appears to be a last-minute panic buy, and while he has potential, his form in England raises concerns.
Transfer Fee: £4 million
Contract Length: Four Years
Travers has not established himself as a first-choice goalkeeper but provides solid backup for Everton.
