As the 2024-25 NHL regular season comes to a close, The Athletic has released an in-depth analysis, providing grades for all 32 teams based on their performance throughout the season. This evaluation considers each team's expectations and results, making it a critical resource for fans and analysts alike as they look forward to the playoffs and the offseason.
The Anaheim Ducks aimed to improve this season, and while they increased their points from 59 last year to 80, their journey was not without challenges. Despite significant strides from young talent like Leo Carlsson, Mason McTavish, and Jackson LaCombe, the Ducks struggled to compete in the second half of the season, failing to make a mark in the wild-card race. Their defense remained inconsistent, and special teams were less than impressive under coach Greg Cronin.
With high expectations for contention, the Boston Bruins faced disappointment, finishing in the bottom five of the league. Their aggressive moves at the trade deadline provided some solace, but ultimately, the season did not meet the aspirations of players and fans alike.
The Buffalo Sabres entered the season with playoff hopes but only managed to regress from their previous 84-point finish. A disastrous 13-game winless streak effectively dashed their postseason ambitions, leading to a disappointing 14th consecutive year without playoff hockey.
Despite finishing just shy of the playoffs, the Calgary Flames exceeded their expectations, thanks to standout performances from rookie goalie Dustin Wolf and veterans Jonathan Huberdeau and Nazem Kadri. However, they face the consequence of trading a first-round pick to Montreal and still need to solidify their roster to compete effectively in the future.
The Carolina Hurricanes had a dynamic season, marked by roster changes and the acquisition of star player Mikko Rantanen. Despite facing skepticism, the Hurricanes finished strong in the Eastern Conference and are poised to make a significant playoff run.
Finishing last again, the Chicago Blackhawks displayed some signs of progress with a younger roster. The surprise trade of Seth Jones opened up new possibilities for the team's future, highlighting the potential of young players like Sam Rinzel and Frank Nazar.
With championship aspirations, the Colorado Avalanche ended up in third place in the Central Division but secured a playoff spot. General manager Chris MacFarland made bold moves to reshape the roster, setting the stage for a deeper playoff run.
Despite missing the playoffs, the Columbus Blue Jackets achieved an impressive season, overcoming adversity following the loss of teammate Johnny Gaudreau. Their strong player performances suggest a brighter future ahead.
The Dallas Stars had a strong season, finishing among the top teams despite significant injuries. Their trade acquisitions bolstered the roster, setting them up as one of the teams to watch in the playoffs.
The Detroit Red Wings aimed for the playoffs but fell short due to a poor start and a late-season collapse. New head coach Todd McLellan's efforts showed promise, but ultimately, the club faced another year outside the postseason.
With hopes for a division title, the Edmonton Oilers encountered injuries and underperformance from key players. Their struggles in the regular season have set the stage for a challenging playoff journey.
Defending their title, the Florida Panthers faced inconsistency but secured a playoff spot. With key players returning from injury, they remain a formidable opponent in the postseason.
The Los Angeles Kings surprised many by tying their franchise record for wins. Their blend of veteran and young talent has set the foundation for a stronger future, pushing them toward playoff success.
Despite significant injuries, the Minnesota Wild managed to reach the playoffs, showcasing resilience and depth within their roster. Their performance this season has laid a strong groundwork for future success.
Against the odds, the Montreal Canadiens turned around their season, making the playoffs after a rocky start. Their young roster gained invaluable experience, positioning them for future competitiveness.
The Nashville Predators endured a dismal season, failing to meet expectations set by management. With disappointing performances and a lack of consistency, the future looks uncertain for the franchise.
Returning to the playoffs, the New Jersey Devils showed promise with strong performances from key players. However, the absence of star player Jack Hughes raises questions about their playoff viability.
The New York Islanders struggled with injuries and finished the season at .500. Their mediocre performance leaves them with more questions than answers heading into the offseason.
The New York Rangers experienced a dramatic fall from grace, missing the playoffs after winning the Presidents’ Trophy last season. A tumultuous year has left management with significant decisions to make.
After eight years away from the playoffs, the Ottawa Senators achieved their goal of postseason play. With key improvements in their roster and performance, they enter the playoffs with confidence.
The Philadelphia Flyers faced a season of challenges, including goaltending woes and a coaching change. While there were bright spots among young players, the overall performance fell short of expectations.
The Pittsburgh Penguins struggled defensively and failed to secure a playoff spot, marking a disappointing season for a franchise accustomed to success. Their defensive issues need immediate attention for future seasons.
With a competitive spirit despite finishing last, the San Jose Sharks showcased young talent. While their record is disappointing, the future looks promising with a strong prospect pipeline.
Despite a lackluster record, the Seattle Kraken demonstrated growth and potential this season. Key performances from new acquisitions hint at a brighter future, but consistency remains a concern.
After a rocky start, the St. Louis Blues rallied under new coach Jim Montgomery, culminating in a playoff berth. Their successful finish showcases resilience and teamwork.
The Tampa Bay Lightning proved their contention window is still open, overcoming offseason changes and re-establishing themselves as one of the league's elite teams.
Winning their first division title in 25 years, the Toronto Maple Leafs had a commendable season, largely due to exceptional goaltending and high-end offensive talent.
Progress marked the Utah Hockey Club's season, improving from last year. While they faced challenges, standout performances from key players suggest potential for next season.
With high hopes, the Vancouver Canucks faced a disappointing season filled with injuries and inconsistencies. The team's future hinges on making substantial adjustments during the offseason.
Continuing their pursuit of the Stanley Cup, the Vegas Golden Knights excelled this season, showcasing depth and resilience. Their ability to adapt to roster changes highlights their championship potential.
The Washington Capitals enjoyed a successful season, highlighted by Alex Ovechkin's record-breaking achievements. Their overall performance solidifies their status as a serious contender.
Achieving a franchise record and the Presidents’ Trophy, the Winnipeg Jets had an exceptional season. Their consistent performance and individual accolades set them up as a formidable playoff contender.
This comprehensive review of NHL team grades for the 2024-25 season not only highlights individual performances but also provides a lens through which fans can understand the broader landscape of the league. As teams prepare for the playoffs, all eyes will be on the outcomes and future implications of these grades.
