The question of whether the New York Giants will target a quarterback in the 2025 NFL Draft has been echoed since the 2024 draft. As the Giants continue to navigate their future, many analysts and scouts have weighed in on the top quarterback prospects likely to capture the team's interest in the first two rounds. Below, we delve into the evaluations of key quarterbacks, including Shedeur Sanders, Jaxson Dart, Tyler Shough, and Jalen Milroe, drawing insights from various draft guides and expert opinions.
Shedeur Sanders from Colorado is a name that has generated significant buzz among scouts. According to Bob McGinn, an NFL writer who consults with scouts, one scout expressed confidence in Sanders, stating, “He’ll start from Day 1 wherever he goes.” The scout highlighted Sanders’ poise and ability to handle pressure, despite facing a challenging offensive line throughout his college career. However, concerns have been raised about his lack of explosive traits and whether his performance would warrant a top-three selection.
Another scout criticized Sanders for being “the flashiest, most overhyped game manager” and argued he should be a second- or third-round pick at best. His inconsistency and tendency to hold onto the ball too long could pose challenges in the NFL.
However, there are also positive assessments of Sanders. Analysts note his strong arm, ability to move in the pocket, and solid work ethic. His experience with high-level coaching and his clean throwing fundamentals have positioned him as a legitimate NFL prospect. Yet, the lingering question remains: can he adapt to the faster pace and complexity of the professional game?
Another intriguing candidate is Jaxson Dart from Ole Miss. Mike Tanier of Too Deep Zone Substack compares Dart to other first-round quarterbacks who have underperformed. He describes Dart as having potential but warns that he might be overdrafted if taken too early. Scouts suggest that while Dart possesses a solid arm and decent mobility, his accuracy is a concern, particularly on deeper throws.
One scout noted Dart’s “moxie and quick-mindedness,” suggesting he might be worth a late second-round pick. However, there are doubts about his ability to handle pressure effectively, with comparisons drawn to past quarterbacks who struggled in similar situations.
Tyler Shough from Louisville presents an interesting case as one of the older prospects in the draft, at 26 years old. McGinn scouts acknowledge Shough's athleticism and arm strength but express concerns about his inconsistency and injury history. Despite this, one scout believes Shough has the tools to be a solid backup and possibly a starting quarterback in the right system.
Shough’s experience at multiple programs has given him a unique perspective, but his age and durability could impede his long-term viability in the league. Analysts suggest that teams drafting Shough should be prepared for a project rather than an instant starter.
Last but not least is Jalen Milroe from Alabama. Milroe is recognized for his athleticism and strong arm, making him a dynamic playmaker. However, scouts have raised concerns about his accuracy and decision-making, particularly under pressure. While he has shown flashes of brilliance, his inconsistent play could lead to challenges in the NFL.
Despite these concerns, Milroe’s raw talent and potential make him an appealing prospect for teams willing to invest time in his development. Analysts emphasize that any team selecting Milroe must be prepared to cultivate his skills over time.
If the Giants are unable to secure a top quarterback in the early rounds, they may consider late-round options like Will Howard from Ohio State and Dillon Gabriel from Oregon. Howard is seen as a sleeper with potential, while Gabriel's size and arm strength have drawn skepticism about his ability to succeed at the NFL level.
As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the Giants' decision regarding a quarterback will be crucial for their long-term success. With various intriguing prospects available, it remains to be seen who will catch their eye and fit their vision for the future.
