In the tradition of films like The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel and the growing genre of “geezer films,” The Thursday Murder Club knows exactly what it aims to achieve: uniting a talented ensemble of seasoned actors, all of whom are, let’s say, in their golden years, to captivate audiences with a charming tale. This delightful mystery revolves around a group of retirees who take on cold cases as a hobby, delivering a narrative that is as gentle as a game of Clue and as cozy as an Agatha Christie novel. While the film may lack originality, its star-studded cast and a sprinkle of self-awareness more than compensate for it.
The Thursday Murder Club offers a modestly entertaining experience, filled with familiar tropes yet unapologetically engaging. Helen Mirren shines in her role as Elizabeth, the mastermind behind the sleuthing activities, occasionally dropping hints of her intriguing past as an intelligence agent. On the other hand, Celia Imrie, known for her work in Better Things, plays Joyce, Elizabeth’s polar opposite. Joyce is a cheerful nurse and the newest member of the club, always bringing delicious home-baked cakes to their meetings.
Ben Kingsley takes on a somewhat lackluster role as Ben, a buttoned-down psychiatrist, but it is Pierce Brosnan who truly steals the show. Brosnan embodies Ron, a former union activist fondly referred to as "Red Ron," who is always ready to rally for a cause. His vibrant portrayal adds a layer of fun and energy to the narrative.
The seniors’ residence, known as Coopers Chase, serves as a whimsical backdrop for the film. This charming locale, converted from a traditional English country house, may not quite reach the grandeur of Downton Abbey, but it certainly offers a picturesque setting. With spacious, comfortable apartments and rolling green lawns, the residence even features llamas, adding to its quirky appeal. Production designer James Merifield infuses the settings with a sense of country estate grandeur, beautifully captured through the lens of cinematographer Don Burgess.
The film's plot thickens when a new murder case arises, overshadowing the club's original cold case investigation. The co-owner of Coopers Chase is found dead, leaving his partner with plans to convert the property into luxury apartments, evicting the elderly residents. David Tennant delivers a witty and exaggerated performance as the villainous partner, while Naomi Ackie, portraying Donna, a young and astute police officer, stands out even in her functional role. The film also features Richard E. Grant, who adds a macabre touch with his late appearance.
Directed by Chris Columbus, known for his work on iconic films like the first two Harry Potter movies and Mrs. Doubtfire, the film is polished and engaging. Columbus brings a smooth deftness to the entire production, ensuring that the cozy tone remains intact. The film even acknowledges its own familiarity, as seen in a humorous exchange between Joyce and Elizabeth. When they take a bus to the police station, Joyce excitedly exclaims, “I feel like we’re in one of those Sunday night dramas about two bright-eyed, feisty old lady detectives outsmarting the police at every turn. Do you feel like that?” Elizabeth’s witty retort, “No. And never use the words bright-eyed, feisty old ladies in my presence again,” delivered with Mirren’s signature acidity, cuts through the feistiness, adding a layer of humor to the script.
While The Thursday Murder Club leans heavily into its plot twists and red herrings, it doesn’t shy away from addressing the reality of aging and mortality. Elizabeth’s husband, played by Jonathan Pryce, shows early signs of dementia, and her best friend is in a coma at the facility’s hospice wing. Despite these poignant themes, the film emphasizes the vibrancy and liveliness of its cast. The closing scene, where Elizabeth and Steven dance to Cat Stevens’ “Oh Very Young,” although a bit on-the-nose, attempts to evoke a sense of poignancy, albeit with a hint of cringe.
In summary, The Thursday Murder Club offers a cozy, entertaining escape filled with warmth, humor, and a touch of mystery, making it a delightful watch for fans of the genre.
