The last time Joe Schoen undertook the task of searching for a head coach for the New York Giants, he interviewed five defensive coaches, including three who had previously served as NFL head coaches. The only other candidate on his list was Brian Daboll, a long-time friend, who ultimately secured the position. After three challenging seasons, Schoen has now fired Daboll. As he embarks on his second search, the direction remains uncertain. However, with young quarterback Jaxson Dart in the fold as a key asset, there’s a strong argument for prioritizing an offensive-minded coach.
Despite the potential benefits of hiring an offensive coach, the Giants' recent history with first-time head coaches, such as Ben McAdoo, Joe Judge, and Daboll, raises concerns. Schoen likely has a list of candidates in mind that will evolve over the next two months. Here’s an informed and speculative look at 11 candidates poised to emerge as the Giants' next head coach.
As the current offensive coordinator for the Giants, Mike Kafka will have the opportunity to impress the team’s owners as the interim head coach for the remaining seven games of the season. The Giants hold Kafka in high regard; he has been a finalist for head coaching positions in Seattle, Arizona, and New Orleans. Providing Dart with stability could be crucial, assuming Kafka demonstrates his capability to lead the team to victory.
The speculation surrounding Mike Tomlin and the possibility of him parting ways with the Steelers has persisted for years. Should that occur, numerous teams would vie for his services. The existing connections between the Giants and Steelers organizations could facilitate a smooth transition. Despite not winning a playoff game since 2016, Tomlin’s proven track record could be appealing to the Giants.
Lane Kiffin is credited with transforming Dart into a first-round draft pick and is regarded as one of the leading offensive minds in college football. However, his previous stint as an NFL head coach with the Raiders ended poorly (5-15 record), making it unlikely the Giants would prioritize him over candidates like those at LSU or Florida.
Bill Belichick has been a subject of interest in every Giants coaching search since Tom Coughlin was let go. Although he still possesses coaching prowess, his reputation has faced scrutiny in recent years. His age (73) and potential distractions, including his personal life, may deter the Giants from pursuing him seriously.
A Super Bowl-winning coach, Mike McCarthy boasts an impressive resume and has a history of maximizing the potential of his offensive teams. Despite a less-than-stellar playoff record, the Giants may find comfort in having a coach capable of leading them to the playoffs.
Kevin Stefanski has twice been named NFL Coach of the Year but currently faces challenges due to the quarterback situation in Cleveland. The Giants had previously sought him as an offensive coordinator in 2018, but his reputation has fluctuated since then. Nevertheless, his two 11-win seasons with the Browns are noteworthy given the organization’s struggles.
Plucking Matt Nagy from the Andy Reid coaching tree could prove beneficial for the Giants. With head coaching experience in Chicago, where he led the team to the playoffs twice, Nagy may bring valuable insights. However, his current ties to the Tennessee Titans could complicate any potential acquisition.
Kliff Kingsbury played a pivotal role in the success of rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels. His previous head coaching experience with the Cardinals was mixed, but his innovative offensive strategies continue to attract attention. Kingsbury may be a sought-after candidate this offseason.
Klint Kubiak is having an impressive season as the offensive coordinator in Seattle, despite challenging circumstances. Although his lack of extensive experience might count against him, his background includes significant roles in successful offensive schemes.
Jeff Hafley is emerging as a hot name in the coaching market, particularly due to the success of the Packers’ defense. As a New Jersey native and former Boston College head coach, Hafley has strong ties to the Giants organization, which may play a significant role in his candidacy.
Lou Anarumo impressed during his interview with the Giants before Schoen hired Daboll. As a Staten Island native, he understands the New York market. After a successful season with the Colts, Anarumo’s past ties with the Giants organization may bolster his chances.
In conclusion, Joe Schoen faces a critical decision in selecting the next head coach for the New York Giants. With a talented quarterback like Jaxson Dart and the team's turbulent coaching history, the choice will be crucial for the franchise's future success.
For more insights and updates on the Giants' coaching search, stay tuned to FOX Sports and follow NFL reporter Ralph Vacchiano on Twitter at @RalphVacchiano.
