The Boston Red Sox have made headlines by agreeing to a three-year, $140 million contract with Alex Bregman. However, this deal effectively functions more like a series of one-year contracts due to Bregman's opt-outs following the 2025 and 2026 seasons. This agreement marks the largest average annual salary ever paid to a Red Sox player, setting the stage for what could be a transformative period for the team.
Though the deal is officially three years, Bregman's ability to leave after each season essentially turns it into a set of one-year agreements. This arrangement offers flexibility for both Bregman and the Red Sox, allowing them to assess performance annually. If Bregman excels, he may explore free agency again, and if he underperforms, the team retains some financial leverage.
The acquisition of Bregman brings much-needed credibility to the Red Sox lineup. Known for his competitive nature and proven track record, Bregman is expected to bolster the team's performance and provide leadership in the clubhouse. His presence should serve as a positive influence on younger players such as Roman Anthony, Marcelo Mayer, and Kristian Campbell.
While Bregman may not be at his All-Star peak, he remains a valuable asset. Despite only two All-Star appearances in 2018 and 2019, Bregman has considerable postseason experience, having played in 99 postseason games and been part of two World Series-winning teams. His all-around skill set and competitive spirit make him a valuable addition to the Red Sox roster.
The effectiveness of Bregman's contract largely depends on his performance. The short-term nature of the deal aligns with the Red Sox's strategy of avoiding long-term commitments, preferring to overpay for shorter durations. This approach provides flexibility, allowing the team to adjust its roster and salary commitments based on Bregman's annual performance.
Bregman is expected to play second base and bat within the top five of the lineup, potentially as high as second or as low as fifth. With left-handed hitters Jarren Duran and Rafael Devers likely batting first and third, right-handed hitters Trevor Story and Bregman will occupy the second and fourth spots. This configuration leverages Story's speed and Bregman's ability to perform with runners in scoring positions.
The Red Sox preferred Bregman over Nolan Arenado due to Bregman's positional flexibility and lesser decline in performance. Bregman can seamlessly transition between second and third base, offering strategic options for the team's future lineup adjustments. This flexibility makes Bregman a more versatile and valuable asset.
From 2022 to 2024, Bregman's OPS declined from .821 to .768, while his OPS+ fell from 134 to 118. Despite this downturn, he remains above average for his position. Notably, Bregman posted an .862 OPS in his last 95 games, highlighting his potential to rebound and contribute significantly to the Red Sox.
Overall, the signing of Alex Bregman is a positive move for the Red Sox. While it doesn't signal a return to high spending, it strengthens the team's lineup and enhances its competitive edge. The 2025 Red Sox are poised to perform better than before, marking a promising start for the upcoming season.
Tony Massarotti is the co-host of the leading afternoon-drive show, Felger & Mazz, on 98.5 The Sports Hub. A lifelong Bostonian, Tony has covered Boston sports for over 20 years and authored several books. He provides in-depth analysis of the Red Sox and MLB through his show, The Baseball Hour, airing weekdays before most Red Sox games.
