By Tim Britton, Johnny Flores Jr., and Andy McCullough
Every week, we gather insights from a diverse group of baseball writers, both local and national, to rank the teams from first to worst. Here are the latest collective results as we dive into the second week of June. At this juncture of the MLB season, a poor start can quickly spiral into a disappointing year. The scoreboard's numbers become harder to change, even after a good homestand or road trip. We're beginning to receive answers to our preseason questions regarding which teams may break out, regress, or surprise us unexpectedly. Now, it’s time to adjust our inquiries. Every organization is on a fact-finding mission over the next 50-plus days leading up to the trade deadline, aiming to identify what is real and what isn't. Therefore, for each of the 30 MLB teams, we pose one crucial question: What must each front office investigate and resolve to fuel a pennant chase, salvage a season, or reinforce a rebuilding strategy?
Record: 43-24 Last Power Ranking: T-2 One big question: Can Detroit keep its pace?
The Detroit Tigers have emerged as the dominant team in the American League (AL) this season, boasting a seven-game lead in the AL Central. As we approach the midway point of the season, it's imperative to assess whether their current success is sustainable. With contributions from players like Jahmai Jones, who recently hit his first home run as a Tiger, and standout pitching from Tarik Skubal, the Tigers have solidified their position. If Detroit can maintain its momentum, it could secure home-field advantage for the playoffs, which would be beneficial for a potential deep October run, especially with their impressive 23-9 home record. Historical precedents suggest we should not underestimate this team.
Record: 42-24 Last Power Ranking: T-2 One big question: How will the top of the rotation shake out?
With a recent string of victories, the New York Mets are in a strong position. The return of Frankie Montas and Sean Manaea before the All-Star break raises questions about the rotation's future. While Paul Blackburn has performed admirably, the key concern for the Mets is identifying the pitchers who can handle the pressure in a postseason environment. As they contemplate their playoff aspirations, the team must determine if Montas and Manaea will meet expectations and whether Kodai Senga can navigate potential regression effectively.
Record: 40-27 Last Power Ranking: 1 One big question: Will the pitchers ever get healthy?
The Los Angeles Dodgers face a dire situation with injuries plaguing their pitching staff. Following the activation of relievers Kirby Yates and Michael Kopech, starter Tony Gonsolin has landed on the injured list, marking the 14th Dodger pitcher sidelined this season. As the team navigates a challenging schedule against rivals San Diego and San Francisco, the upcoming weeks will clarify whether they can maintain their position without their best arms available.
Record: 39-25 Last Power Ranking: 4 One big question: Can the bullpen get by without its closer?
Despite the spotlight on Aaron Judge, the New York Yankees' bullpen has been a hallmark of reliability over the years. However, as they now face the challenge of navigating several weeks without their key closer, Devin Williams, the Yankees must assess their bullpen's depth. Williams' recent performances will be crucial in determining whether the Yankees need to bolster their relief options before the trade deadline.
Record: 40-26 Last Power Ranking: 5 One big question: Will Jed Hoyer’s front office be given clearance to go all-in?
After two consecutive seasons with 83 wins, the Chicago Cubs are on the brink of returning to the postseason for the first time since 2018. With an impressive offensive output and solid pitching performance, the Cubs must decide whether to make significant moves at the trade deadline. The front office's willingness to invest in additional talent could be pivotal for a deep playoff run.
Record: 38-28 Last Power Ranking: 8 One big question: Will Buster Posey’s big shakeup boost the offense?
In a bid to revitalize a stagnant offense, Buster Posey has implemented several roster changes, including trading first baseman LaMonte Wade Jr. for Dominic Smith. The Giants responded positively with a five-game winning streak. However, the offense needs to capitalize on these changes if they hope to remain competitive in the NL West.
Record: 38-28 Last Power Ranking: 6 One big question: Can the bullpen be salvaged on the fly?
The Philadelphia Phillies have grappled with bullpen issues this season, which were highlighted in a recent game. The trade that brought Jordan Romano to Philadelphia has not yielded the expected results, and the absence of key relievers has raised concerns. With the trade market for relievers expected to be active, the Phillies must act swiftly to rectify their bullpen struggles.
Record: 37-28 Last Power Ranking: 7 One big question: Can the rotation hold up without Michael King and Yu Darvish?
The San Diego Padres are entering a critical stretch, facing the Dodgers in a series without two of their top pitchers. The team will need to lean on their remaining starters and hope that their inexperienced pitchers can step up during this crucial time.
Record: 36-29 Last Power Ranking: 11 One big question: When will Yordan Alvarez return?
Yordan Alvarez's absence due to a fractured right hand has raised concerns for the Houston Astros, who are currently leading the AL West. Although the team has managed to stay competitive, Alvarez's return is critical for the Astros' postseason aspirations.
Record: 36-30 Last Power Ranking: 11 One big question: What do you do at the deadline?
The St. Louis Cardinals are in a strong position for a Wild Card spot, but they face tough decisions heading into the trade deadline. Balancing the potential for postseason success with the need for future development will be key for the front office.
As we move forward in the MLB season, these questions will shape the landscape of baseball and determine the fate of each franchise as they navigate the trade deadline and beyond.
