The memory of Reggie Miller's eight points in 8.9 seconds is etched in basketball lore, and it has now found a new chapter in the storied history of New York Knicks playoff collapses. This latest heart-wrenching episode unfolded during the Eastern Conference Finals, where the Knicks squandered an impressive 17-point fourth-quarter lead, ultimately succumbing to the Indiana Pacers in a shocking overtime defeat.
The Knicks kicked off the series against the Pacers with high hopes, having previously rallied from 20-point deficits to upset the Celtics. However, Game 1 quickly transformed from a promising start to a catastrophic outcome for the Knicks. Despite leading 138-135 in overtime, the Knicks could not secure the victory, leaving the home crowd at Madison Square Garden in disbelief.
In a historic turn of events, the Knicks became the first team in the play-by-play era (since 1997) to lead a playoff game by 14 points with just 2:45 remaining and ultimately lose. The previous record stood at 994-0 for teams in that position. This shocking defeat marked the first time since 1998 that a team had blown a nine-point lead in the final minute of a playoff game, according to the Elias Sports Bureau. The Knicks' record was now marred by this unprecedented collapse.
In the aftermath, Coach Tom Thibodeau urged his team to focus on the next game. "We gotta be ready for Game 2," he stated. "That’s all you can look at. So you take disappointment, turn that into more determination.” His message resonated amidst the disappointment as the Knicks looked to regroup and bounce back.
Aaron Nesmith's explosive performance in the fourth quarter was pivotal for the Pacers. He drilled six 3-pointers, turning the tide of the game and leading his team to a commanding comeback. Meanwhile, crucial free throws missed by Karl-Anthony Towns and OG Anunoby in the final seconds of regulation proved costly for the Knicks. In a dramatic twist, a potential game-winning shot from Tyrese Haliburton was ruled a 2-pointer, ensuring the game went into overtime.
Overtime proved to be equally frustrating for the Knicks. Although they scored the first four points, they were outscored 13-6 in the remaining minutes. The team struggled offensively, managing only six points in the last 3:11 of the extra period. "We didn’t run through that finish line," Josh Hart said, highlighting the team's defensive lapses and stagnant offense.
Despite the loss, Jalen Brunson had an impressive outing, scoring 43 points, while Towns contributed 35 points and 12 rebounds. However, Brunson's seven turnovers, including two critical ones in the closing moments, hampered the Knicks' chances. The Pacers' Haliburton shined with 31 points and 11 assists, while Nesmith's late-game surge added 22 of his 30 points in the fourth quarter alone.
The Knicks' collapse in Game 1 serves as a stark reminder of the pressures of playoff basketball. As they prepare for Game 2, the team must channel their disappointment into determination. "In the playoffs, when you win it’s the best thing ever. When you lose, it’s the worst thing ever," Brunson reflected. The Knicks must remain levelheaded and support one another as they navigate the challenges ahead in the postseason.
For ongoing coverage of the Knicks' journey in the 2025 NBA Playoffs, make sure to follow The Post and subscribe for in-depth analysis and insider updates on the series.
