As we move further into the 2025 NFL free agency period, it’s time to evaluate the Washington Commanders and their recent roster moves. After taking a closer look at the Dallas Cowboys earlier this week, we’ll now analyze how the Commanders have fared in their quest to enhance their team. Let’s break down the players gained, retained, and lost, along with an overall assessment of their free agency strategy.
The Commanders made headlines by trading for WR Deebo Samuel. The team sent a fifth-round pick to the San Francisco 49ers in exchange for the talented receiver. This move has drawn mixed reviews, raising questions about Samuel's recent performance. In 2021, he was a standout player, recording 77 receptions for 1,405 yards and six touchdowns, alongside 365 rushing yards and eight touchdowns. However, his production has significantly declined over the last two seasons, culminating in a disappointing 2024 where he managed just 670 receiving yards.
Despite the fanfare surrounding his acquisition, the Commanders must also contend with Samuel's hefty salary of $17.5 million for the upcoming season. This raises concerns about whether the investment aligns with the team's long-term goals, especially when comparing him to younger talents like Dyami Brown and Olamide Zaccheaus.
Another notable addition is LT Laremy Tunsil, acquired in a trade that cost the Commanders a second, third, and seventh-round pick. Tunsil, who will count for $21.35 million against the cap over the next two seasons, brings experience but also a history of penalties. His trade raises eyebrows, especially considering the Houston Texans were willing to part ways with him despite needing protection for franchise quarterback C.J. Stroud.
The Commanders also signed iDL Javon Kinlaw to a surprising three-year deal worth $45 million. Kinlaw has struggled with run defense throughout his career, making this signing one of the more baffling moves of the offseason. Meanwhile, S Will Harris and CB Jonathan Jones were brought in to add depth and versatility to the secondary.
In terms of retaining talent, the Commanders decided to keep quarterback Marcus Mariota, who will earn $8 million in 2025. Additionally, the team brought back several others, including running back Jeremy McNichols and tight end Zach Ertz, who had a solid 2024 season with 66 catches and seven touchdowns.
However, the retention of aging players like LB Bobby Wagner, who had a commendable season but is approaching the end of his career, raises concerns about the team's direction. Wagner’s experience is invaluable, but the Commanders also need to focus on building a younger roster.
The Commanders faced some tough losses as well, including DT Jonathan Allen, who signed with the Minnesota Vikings for a significant three-year deal worth $60 million. Allen’s departure leaves a gap in the defensive line that will be hard to fill. Additionally, they lost key players such as EDGE Dante Fowler and S Jeremy Chinn, further complicating their defensive situation.
Reflecting on the Commanders' free agency strategy, it’s clear they are making some questionable decisions. While they enjoyed success last season with a playoff appearance, they now seem to be leaning heavily on veteran players, many of whom are 30 years or older. With a total of 19 players over 30 or turning 30 soon, the team risks undermining its long-term potential.
Comparatively, teams like the Philadelphia Eagles are focusing on younger talent, which could lead to sustained success. The Commanders’ draft capital is also limited, having traded away valuable picks for aging veterans. Moving forward, a more balanced approach that incorporates younger players alongside experienced veterans could yield better results.
Overall, given the questionable moves made and the concerns surrounding the roster's age, I would assign the Commanders a grade of D for their 2025 free agency period. They need to refocus their strategy on building a team that not only competes now but also has a bright future ahead.
For more insights on NFL free agency and team strategies, follow us on Twitter and Facebook at PhillyVoice Sports.
