In a surprising turn of events for fans and analysts alike, DJ LeMahieu's time with the New York Yankees has come to an abrupt conclusion. After manager Aaron Boone revealed that LeMahieu would be transitioned to a bench role, the team followed up by designating him for assignment just one day later. This decision marks the end of LeMahieu's seven-year career in pinstripes, a tenure filled with both highs and lows.
The Yankees face significant financial repercussions due to this move. If no other team claims LeMahieu, the organization will need to cover approximately $22 million, which includes the remainder of his $15 million salary for the current season and an additional $15 million due in 2026. This financial burden is a reflection of the contract he signed—a six-year, $90 million extension—following a standout 2020 season where he finished third in the American League MVP race.
Manager Aaron Boone spoke candidly about the difficult decision, stating, “It’s been a tough couple of days, some hard conversations, and then ultimately coming to this decision, obviously not easy for what’s been a great player.” Boone acknowledged the contributions LeMahieu made to the organization but felt the need to make this choice for the team's future. Notably, Boone confirmed that LeMahieu did not request his release, indicating that the decision was made mutually after discussions with general manager Brian Cashman.
With LeMahieu's departure, the Yankees have made adjustments to their roster, bringing in infielder Jorbit Vivas to fill the 26-man roster spot. Jazz Chisholm Jr. will now shift to second base, while the team evaluates options at third base, including Oswald Peraza, Vivas, and JC Escarra. This reshuffling illustrates the Yankees' commitment to optimizing their lineup following LeMahieu's exit.
At 36 years old, LeMahieu's performance has significantly declined, especially since the start of the 2021 season. His wRC+ (Weighted Runs Created Plus) of 99 ranks as the 20th worst among all major league hitters with at least 2,000 plate appearances. The decline in his offensive capabilities, coupled with recurring lower-body injuries, has rendered him a less versatile player. Boone noted that LeMahieu faced physical challenges while playing third base, which ultimately contributed to the decision to move him to the bench.
Despite the recent challenges, LeMahieu's legacy in New York is notable. He leaves behind a career that includes two top-five finishes in MVP voting, two Silver Slugger Awards, and a Gold Glove Award as a utility infielder in 2022. His contributions to the Yankees during his time with the team will not be forgotten, as he was a key player in their successes.
As the Yankees move forward, they must grapple with the implications of losing a veteran presence like LeMahieu, while also looking to build a competitive roster for the future. With the landscape of their lineup evolving, fans will be keen to see how the team adapts in the wake of this significant change.
— The Athletic’s Brendan Kuty contributed to this report. (Photo: New York Yankees / Getty Images)
