The reviews are in for Arch Manning’s much-anticipated season debut as the starting quarterback for Texas, and the feedback has been decidedly mixed. Following the 14-7 loss to Ohio State, one scout candidly remarked to Fox Sports that the game was “a little hard to watch.” Despite this, some industry experts urged fans and analysts to exercise patience with the young quarterback as he navigates the pressures of being in the spotlight.
During Manning’s debut on Saturday afternoon in Columbus, a significant number of professional scouts were in attendance, with representatives from 22 NFL teams and a total of 33 scouts closely observing the action. Manning’s performance included completing 17 of 30 pass attempts for 170 yards, accompanied by one touchdown and one interception. Additionally, he showcased his mobility by rushing 10 times for 39 yards.
One NFC scout expressed that Manning was placed in a “lose-lose situation” due to the immense hype surrounding him prior to the game, admitting he expected better performance from the young quarterback. “Honestly, it was a little hard to watch,” the scout stated. “He’s just been hyped up so much. Almost no matter what he did, he couldn’t have met those expectations. But I will admit that I thought he’d be better than he was.”
Another scout acknowledged the strength of the Ohio State secondary, highlighting that several players on that team will likely play “in the league” in the future, suggesting that the formidable competition may have impacted Manning’s performance.
As public opinion on Manning shifts, two scouts emphasized that it is “too early in the process” to draw definitive conclusions about his abilities. “He’ll be fine,” an AFC scout assured. “Texas coach Steve Sarkisian will coach him up. You guys in the media made the mistake of overhyping him based on two games last year. Don’t make the same mistake of doubting him now based on one bad game to start this year.”
Former Jets scout Daniel Kelly took to X to share his perspective, stating that he was encouraged by certain aspects of Manning’s performance after what he described as a “robotic” first quarter. “I’m actually encouraged by what Manning put on tape against Ohio State,” Kelly wrote. “He’s shown improvement in several key areas. He’s gotten better at seeing the whole field. He’s better at going through his progressions and delivering more accurately on his second and third reads. And he’s a LOT better at feeling pressure.”
Kelly pointed out that Manning demonstrated the ability to evade danger during several plays against Ohio State, successfully picking up yardage with his legs or sidestepping pressure while maintaining his focus downfield.
As Arch Manning embarks on his journey as the starting quarterback for Texas, the mixed reviews serve as a reminder of the challenges and expectations that come with the position. With the support of his coaching staff and the patience of fans, the young quarterback has the potential to grow and refine his skills as the season progresses.
