Welcome to The Athletic's comprehensive analysis of the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft. This detailed breakdown assesses which teams successfully addressed their needs with potential star players and which general managers (GMs) might face regrets about their decisions in the future. While the full impact of these picks won't be clear until the new rookie class has spent a few seasons in the league, our immediate grades consider several factors, including pick value, trade cost, and the availability of other talented prospects at the time of selection.
The Tennessee Titans had a pressing need for a quarterback, and they found their answer in Cam Ward, who is widely regarded as the best quarterback in this draft class. Ward possesses the talent and grit that will resonate with both his teammates and the Titans' fanbase. Although it's speculative, one might wonder how Ward would have fared in last year's draft or if the Titans would have chosen one of the six first-round quarterbacks from the 2024 draft over him. Regardless, Ward's skill set positions him for potential success in the NFL. During his college career, Ward set an NCAA record with 158 career touchdown passes and threw for 18,184 yards, boasting a 65.1 completion percentage. Last season, he amassed 4,313 yards, 39 touchdowns, and just seven interceptions. Grade: B+
Travis Hunter is arguably the best football player in this draft, and his versatility makes him a rare talent. He can compete at a high level in two of the most demanding positions on the field, cornerback and wide receiver. The Jaguars' strategy may involve starting Hunter as a corner while gradually introducing him as a wide receiver. This trade was beneficial for both teams: Jacksonville moved up to No. 2, adding a fourth and sixth-round pick, while Cleveland received the fifth pick along with a second and fourth-round pick in this draft and a future first-round pick. The Jaguars are closer to contention than many believe, and this pick enhances their roster significantly. Grade: A
The New York Giants made a wise decision by selecting Abdul Carter, the best player available, instead of succumbing to the pressure of drafting for need. Carter excelled as an edge rusher at Penn State and will complement Brian Burns in the Giants' 3-4 defense. He is expected to challenge Kayvon Thibodeaux for playing time, if not a starting position. Carter's transition from linebacker to edge rusher last season led to an impressive season that included 12 sacks and 23.5 tackles for loss. His determination was evident as he played through a serious shoulder injury during the College Football Playoff. Grade: A
Will Campbell has emerged as the top offensive lineman in this draft, and the Patriots made a safe choice by selecting him. Despite some concerns about his length at left tackle, his hand and footwork are exceptional for a three-year college player. This pick addresses an urgent need for a team looking to rebuild around its young quarterback, providing a strong foundation for future success. Grade: A
Mason Graham, a powerful interior defender, was a standout on Michigan's defense. His selection by the Browns aligns perfectly with their 4-3 defensive scheme, where he will team up with Myles Garrett and bolster a run defense that struggled last season. Cleveland made a smart move by opting for the best player available rather than reaching for a position of need. Graham's accolades include being named a consensus first-team All-American and the Rose Bowl MVP. Grade: A
Ashton Jeanty is a modern-day running back with extraordinary versatility, reminiscent of LaDainian Tomlinson. He is a true three-down back capable of excelling in any offensive system. Last season, Jeanty rushed for 2,601 yards and scored 29 touchdowns, establishing himself as one of college football's most productive running backs since Barry Sanders. His ability to dominate both inside and outside makes him a valuable addition to the Raiders. Grade: A
The Jets opted for substance over flash with the selection of Armand Membou, who will help solidify their offensive line. Membou joins last year's top pick, Olu Fashanu, as a cornerstone for the Jets' offensive front. While the Jets' emphasis on strengthening their offensive line is commendable, it remains to be seen if this strategy outweighs the need for additional offensive weapons. Grade: B
Tetairoa McMillan is a versatile receiver with excellent ball skills and catch radius. His college tape is filled with spectacular catches that resulted in significant yardage. While there are concerns regarding his speed and effectiveness against press coverage, McMillan's track record of 213 catches for 3,423 yards and 26 touchdowns in three years is impressive. Despite having multiple needs, the Panthers made a solid choice with this pick. Grade: B+
Despite investing heavily in their offensive line in recent drafts, the Saints opted to draft Kelvin Banks Jr. with this pick. While Banks has the potential to become a key player, the Saints might have benefited more from addressing their defensive needs, especially considering last season's struggles. Banks' accolades include starting every game of his college career and winning the Lombardi and Outland Trophy. Grade: C
Colston Loveland emerged as one of the top tight ends in this draft, and he will be a valuable receiving option for the Bears. Drawing comparisons to Detroit Lions' standout Sam LaPorta, Loveland's receiving skills make him a perfect fit for the Bears' offensive scheme. While Tyler Warren may excel as a blocker, Loveland's receiving ability sets him apart. Grade: A
The 49ers addressed their need for a complementary edge rusher alongside Nick Bosa by selecting Mykel Williams. Although Williams faced injuries during his college career, he still managed to produce impressive numbers. His size and physicality make him a valuable asset, and the 49ers are banking on his potential for long-term success. Grade: A
Tyler Booker is a powerhouse and the top run-blocking offensive lineman in this draft. While some concerns about his quickness exist, his physical dominance and potential as a guard make him an excellent selection for the Cowboys. Dallas has a solid track record of evaluating offensive line talent, and Booker is poised to make an immediate impact. Grade: B+
Although Kenneth Grant was selected earlier than anticipated, he fits well into the Dolphins' 3-4 defense. His ability to occupy blockers and disrupt plays makes him a vital addition to Miami's defensive front. Grant's impressive college performance included 11.5 tackles for loss and 6.5 sacks over the past two seasons. Grade: B
Tyler Warren's selection fills a critical need for the Colts as they look to enhance their tight end position. With his ability to block and catch, Warren is expected to make an immediate impact. He played a multifaceted role at Penn State, showcasing his versatility and skill set. This pick represents great value for a team that needed it. Grade: A
Jalon Walker's selection was a perfect blend of need and value for the Falcons. He was a dynamic player at Georgia and won the Butkus Award as the top linebacker in the nation. His explosiveness and ability to pressure the quarterback make him a valuable asset for Atlanta's defense. Grade: A+
Walter Nolen, a highly touted recruit, has shown flashes of brilliance but has struggled with consistency. The Cardinals are betting on Nolen's potential to develop into a star, but some may question the decision to draft him over other talent on the board. Grade: B-
Shemar Stewart's selection carries significant risk, as he has the potential to be a top-tier pass rusher but has yet to produce consistent results. His physical attributes are impressive, but he must improve his finishing ability to justify this pick. Grade: C
Grey Zabel's versatility makes him an excellent choice for the Seahawks, who have struggled to solidify their interior offensive line. Zabel's performance at the Senior Bowl showcased his potential, and he is expected to contribute immediately. Grade: A+
While Emeka Egbuka is a talented receiver, the Buccaneers' pressing needs on defense may have warranted a different selection. Nevertheless, Egbuka is an exceptional route runner who can thrive in critical situations alongside established stars. Grade: C-
Jahdae Barron is an elite playmaker who adds depth to the Broncos' secondary. Although Denver had various options, Barron's character and leadership qualities make him a valuable addition to the team. Grade: B+
Pittsburgh made a bold move by selecting Derrick Harmon, a powerful defensive tackle who can bolster their run defense. Harmon brings a blend of size and athleticism that the Steelers desperately need. Grade: A
Omarion Hampton's selection addresses a significant need for the Chargers, who were lacking a dynamic running back in their offense. His versatility as a three-down back makes him a perfect fit for Los Angeles, complementing their offensive strategy. Grade: A
Matthew Golden's selection marks a significant moment for the Packers, as they haven't drafted a receiver in the first round since 2002. His speed and ability to stretch the field will benefit the Packers' offense, especially with Christian Watson's recent injury. Grade: A
Donovan Jackson's versatility makes him a valuable pick for the Vikings, who are focused on improving their offensive line. While he has excelled at guard, his ability to play tackle adds depth to their roster. Grade: B
The Giants made a strategic move by trading back into the first round to select Jaxson Dart. With experienced quarterbacks in place to mentor him, Dart has time to develop into a future starter. His impressive collegiate performance bodes well for his NFL prospects. Grade: A
The Falcons gave up significant assets to move up for James Pearce Jr., a player with tremendous potential but questions about his consistency. If he can harness his talent, he could become a valuable contributor on Atlanta's defense. Grade: C+
Malaki Starks was a key player on Georgia's defense, and his selection enhances the Ravens' secondary. While cornerback may have been a bigger need, Starks' elite ability makes this pick worthwhile. Grade: B
Tyleik Williams is an underrated player who can make an immediate impact on the Lions' defensive front. His selection addresses a pressing need while providing the team with a strong run defender. Grade: B
Washington's aggressive approach to improving their offensive line continues with the selection of Josh Conerly Jr. His experience and performance at Oregon make him a valuable addition to protect their quarterback, Jayden Daniels. Grade: B
Maxwell Hairston's speed and competitiveness make him an excellent choice for the Bills' secondary. While there are questions over whether he should have been picked over other available options, Hairston is a solid addition. Grade: B
The Eagles' trade-up to select Jihaad Campbell reflects their commitment to adding impactful players to their defense. Campbell's playmaking ability and versatility should enhance Philadelphia's defensive lineup significantly. Grade: A
Josh Simmons is an excellent value pick for the Chiefs, who are adept at finding talent late in the first round. If Simmons can overcome his recent injury, he has the potential to become a top-tier offensive lineman. Grade: A
